"Should I get encapsulation or just a vapor barrier?" It's the question we hear most from homeowners. And it's a fair question — the price difference between the two is significant, and contractors sometimes blur the line between them.
The short answer: a vapor barrier is one component of encapsulation. Encapsulation includes a vapor barrier but goes much further. Which one you need depends on your crawl space's current condition, your climate, and how much protection you want.
Let's break down exactly what each option involves, what it costs, how effective it is, and how to decide which one makes sense for your home.
What Is a Vapor Barrier?
A vapor barrier is a moisture-resistant membrane — typically a polyethylene sheet — installed on the crawl space floor to prevent ground moisture from evaporating into the space above. Ground moisture is the single largest source of water vapor in most crawl spaces. In a typical 1,500 sq ft crawl space, the exposed dirt floor can release 15-20 gallons of water vapor per day into the air.
A vapor barrier blocks this ground moisture. The barrier is laid across the entire floor, with seams overlapped by at least 6 inches and sealed with specialized tape. In some installations, the barrier extends 6–12 inches up the foundation walls and is secured with fasteners. The crawl space vents remain open, and no dehumidifier is installed.
Vapor Barrier Specs
- •Material: Polyethylene sheeting (6, 12, or 20 mil thickness)
- •Coverage: Crawl space floor, sometimes extending partially up walls
- •Sealing: Seams taped but vents remain open
- •Dehumidification: Not included
- •Wall treatment: Minimal or none
- •Typical lifespan: 10–20+ years depending on thickness
Learn more on our vapor barrier installation page.
What Is Encapsulation?
Encapsulation is a complete moisture control system that seals the crawl space from the outside environment. It includes a vapor barrier but adds several critical components that address moisture from all sources — not just the ground.
In an encapsulated crawl space, a heavy-duty vapor barrier (typically 12–20 mil) covers the entire floor and extends fully up the foundation walls, where it's secured and sealed. All foundation vents are permanently closed. Gaps around pipes, wires, and penetrations are sealed. A commercial-grade dehumidifier maintains humidity below 55%. The result is a clean, dry, conditioned space that's effectively part of your home's interior environment.
Encapsulation Specs
- •Material: Heavy-duty polyethylene (12–20 mil, reinforced)
- •Coverage: Entire floor AND full wall coverage to sill plate
- •Sealing: All seams taped, all vents closed, all gaps sealed
- •Dehumidification: Commercial-grade unit included (70-100+ pints/day)
- •Wall treatment: Vapor barrier sealed to walls, often with insulation
- •Typical lifespan: 15–25+ years
Read our complete encapsulation guide for a full breakdown of how it works.
Side-by-Side Comparison
When a Vapor Barrier Is Enough
A standalone vapor barrier — without full encapsulation — can be adequate in specific situations:
- →Dry climate: In arid regions (Southwest, Mountain West) where ambient humidity is consistently low, ground moisture is the primary concern. A vapor barrier addresses this without the need for dehumidification.
- →Minimal moisture issues: If your crawl space has no mold, no standing water, and humidity stays below 60% most of the year, a quality vapor barrier may be all the protection you need.
- →Budget constraint: A $2,000 vapor barrier is significantly better than doing nothing. If full encapsulation isn't in the budget, a vapor barrier provides meaningful protection and can be upgraded to encapsulation later.
- →Newer construction: Some newer homes with well-built crawl spaces, good drainage, and no history of moisture may only need a vapor barrier for code compliance and basic protection.
- →Pre-sale improvement: If you're selling and the crawl space is in decent shape, a professional vapor barrier installation can help pass inspection at a fraction of encapsulation cost.
Not Sure Which One You Need?
A free professional inspection will tell you exactly what your crawl space needs — whether that's a vapor barrier, full encapsulation, or something in between.
Step 1 of 3
What do you need help with?
When You Need Full Encapsulation
Encapsulation is the better choice — and often the necessary one — when:
- →Humid climate: In the Southeast, Gulf Coast, Mid-Atlantic, and Pacific Northwest, ambient humidity regularly drives moisture into crawl spaces through open vents. A vapor barrier on the floor can't control humidity from the air. You need sealed vents and a dehumidifier.
- →Active moisture problems: If you have mold, musty odors, condensation on pipes, or humidity above 60%, ground moisture isn't the only issue. Airborne moisture needs to be controlled with vent sealing and dehumidification.
- →Pest problems: Open vents and unsealed gaps invite pests. Encapsulation seals these entry points while eliminating the damp conditions that attract moisture-loving insects and rodents.
- →Energy efficiency goals: A vapor barrier alone provides minimal energy savings because the vents remain open. Encapsulation — especially with wall insulation — brings the crawl space into your home's thermal envelope, reducing energy costs by 15-20%.
- →Health concerns: If family members suffer from allergies, asthma, or respiratory issues, a vapor barrier alone won't solve the air quality problem. Encapsulation seals the space and conditions the air, dramatically reducing allergens and mold spores entering your home.
- →Long-term ownership: If you plan to stay in your home for 5+ years, encapsulation's higher upfront cost is offset by energy savings, avoided repairs, and increased home value over time.
Cost Comparison: The Real Numbers
The upfront cost difference is significant, but the long-term economics tell a different story:
An important pattern: many homeowners who install a vapor barrier first end up upgrading to full encapsulation within a few years when the vapor barrier doesn't fully resolve their moisture issues. At that point, they've spent money twice — the vapor barrier installation plus the encapsulation. If your crawl space clearly needs encapsulation, doing it right the first time is almost always more cost-effective. For complete pricing details, see our encapsulation cost guide.
Decision Guide: Which One Do You Need?
Answer these questions to guide your decision:
Is your crawl space humidity regularly above 60%?
A vapor barrier alone won't solve this. You need vent sealing + dehumidification → encapsulation.
Do you see mold, smell musty odors, or have condensation on pipes?
These are airborne moisture problems that a floor-only barrier can't fix → encapsulation.
Do you live in a humid climate (Southeast, Gulf Coast, Pacific NW)?
Climate will constantly drive moisture through open vents → encapsulation.
Is your crawl space dry, in an arid climate, with no visible issues?
A quality vapor barrier may be all you need → vapor barrier.
Are energy bills a concern?
Only encapsulation provides meaningful energy savings → encapsulation.
Is budget the primary constraint?
A vapor barrier is better than nothing and can be upgraded later → vapor barrier now, encapsulation later.
Can You Start with a Vapor Barrier and Upgrade Later?
Yes — and this is a reasonable approach if budget is the limiting factor. A professionally installed vapor barrier provides real protection against ground moisture and is a meaningful first step. If conditions worsen or you want more comprehensive protection later, encapsulation can be added on top of the existing vapor barrier.
The caveat: you'll pay for labor twice. The vapor barrier may need to be partially removed and repositioned during encapsulation. In total, the phased approach typically costs 15–25% more than doing encapsulation from the start. But if the alternative is doing nothing because full encapsulation isn't affordable right now, a vapor barrier is absolutely the right call.
The Bottom Line
A vapor barrier is a floor-level moisture block. Encapsulation is a complete environmental control system. The right choice depends on your crawl space's condition, your climate, and your goals.
For most homes in humid climates with any signs of moisture problems, encapsulation is the more effective and cost-efficient solution over time. For dry crawl spaces in arid climates, a quality vapor barrier may be all you need.
The best way to know for sure? Have a professional inspect your crawl space. Most contractors offer free assessments and can tell you honestly whether you need full encapsulation or a simpler solution. Learn more about encapsulation and vapor barrier installation, or read about whether encapsulation is worth the investment.